Skip to main content
Honeywell Carmel Indoor Ceiling Fan

Honeywell

Carmel Indoor Ceiling Fan

8.2/10
Based on 3 reviews

Affiliate Disclosure: We may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site. This does not influence our editorial recommendations. Learn more about how we make money

8.5

Clara’s Verdict

Excellent

A beautiful, whisper-quiet ceiling fan that cools efficiently and won't break the budget.

Best for: busy families who want set-it-and-forget-it cooling, anyone who hates noisy fans, people who want their fan to look nice, budget-conscious shoppers

Skip if: people who need precise remote feedback, those who prefer pull-chain simplicity

7.5

Ethan’s Verdict

Very Good

Excellent airflow and quiet operation are hampered by a poorly designed remote that can't reliably indicate power state.

Best for: Budget-conscious buyers, Silent operation priority, High-airflow needs

Skip if: Smart home integrators, Those wanting intuitive controls, Remote-dependent users

Clara’s Pros & Cons

  • +Silent operation even on highest speeds
  • +Moves tons of air efficiently and cools quickly
  • +Looks expensive but costs under $150
  • +Easy installation and lifetime warranty
  • Remote doesn't show on/off status clearly
  • Pull chains require cycling through all settings
  • Need to watch fan to confirm it's off

Ethan’s Pros & Cons

  • +5,202 CFM airflow is exceptional for the price tier
  • +Completely silent operation across all speeds
  • +Looks premium despite affordable cost
  • +Lifetime warranty and reliable build quality
  • Remote lacks power-state indicator, causing user confusion
  • Pull-chain controls are outdated and frustrating
  • No smart home integration or modern conveniences
  • Price creep on Amazon ($199.99) erodes value proposition

Score Breakdown

Performance
9.012% wt
Quality
8.515% wt
Design
9.020% wt
Features
8.010% wt
Ease of Use
7.520% wt
Durability
8.510% wt
Value
9.013% wt

Score Breakdown

Performance
8.525% wt
Quality
8.015% wt
Design
8.012% wt
Features
6.515% wt
Ease of Use
6.012% wt
Durability
8.012% wt
Value
8.59% wt

Clara’s Full Review

A Fan That Actually Looks Good

Honestly, most ceiling fans are functional but boring. They're the appliance equivalent of a beige wall. The Honeywell Carmel is different. It has this sophisticated matte black finish with nickel hardware that makes it feel like a design choice, not just something you tolerate in the ceiling.

Reviewers were genuinely impressed by how premium it looks for the price. It works in contemporary spaces, transitional homes, or anywhere you want something that doesn't scream "basic ceiling fan."

Performance That's Actually Impressive

This isn't just a pretty face. The Carmel moves 5,202 cubic feet of air per minute, which is serious cooling power. Reviewers tested it over six months and found it efficiently circulated air without any of the wobbling, vibration, or noise that drives you crazy with cheap fans.

Best part? It's completely silent. You can run it on high speed and barely hear a whisper. That matters when you're sleeping, working from home, or trying to watch TV. The auto shutoff function is a nice bonus too.

The Remote Control Thing

Here's the one quirk: the remote doesn't have a light showing whether the fan is on or off. So if you can't see the blades moving, you might press the button twice thinking it's off when it's actually on. It's not a dealbreaker, just something to know. The pull chains work too, but you have to cycle through all the settings, which is more annoying than a simple remote.

Easy to Install, Built to Last

Installation is straightforward, and it comes with a lifetime warranty. That's the kind of confidence you want from a fan manufacturer. Reviewers had zero issues with wobbling, noise, or performance over months of daily use.

Who Should Buy This

If you want a ceiling fan that cools efficiently, looks beautiful, doesn't cost a fortune, and won't drive you crazy with noise, this is it. It's perfect for bedrooms, living rooms, or anywhere you need reliable cooling without the eyesore.

Clara Mercer, Home & Lifestyle Editor

Ethan’s Full Review

The Carmel Delivers Performance, But Control Design Lets It Down

Honeywell's Carmel ceiling fan occupies an interesting market position: genuinely competent hardware held back by mediocre controls. Let's break down what's actually happening here.

On the performance side, this is legitimate engineering. The 5,202 CFM output is substantial. For context, that's not a number you see often at sub-$200 price points. Testing showed silent operation across all speeds with zero vibration or wobbling, which is harder to achieve than manufacturers typically admit. The motor is clearly well-tuned. Better Homes & Gardens ran this for six months in actual living spaces and reported zero performance degradation. That's the kind of real-world validation that matters more than synthetic specs.

Build quality is where the Carmel punches above its weight. Metal construction, satin nickel hardware, matte black blades. It doesn't just perform well, it looks like a $300+ fan at $150. That's not hype. That's the design doing its job.

But here's where I have to get critical: the control interface is genuinely bad.

The remote doesn't indicate when the fan is off. This forces users into a frustrating workflow: press the button, then visually confirm the fan actually stopped. That's a basic UX failure. Worse, you cycle through all settings with pull chains to turn things off, which is 2005 thinking. At $200, you're in a price range where users expect better. Modern ceiling fans at this tier have multi-speed remotes, wall controls, and intuitive feedback. The Carmel feels like Honeywell saved $3 per unit on the remote to hit a price target.

There's also no smart home integration. No WiFi module, no app control, nothing. Again, sub-$200 fans in 2024 often include basic WiFi. This isn't a deal-breaker for everyone, but it's worth noting the feature gap.

The lifetime warranty is solid. That signals confidence in durability, and testing backs it up.

So here's the business case: if you prioritize raw airflow and silent operation and can tolerate clunky controls, the Carmel is a strong buy. The performance-per-dollar is genuinely excellent. But if you want modern conveniences or intuitive controls, you're paying for hardware that feels like it was designed three years ago.

Value is the saving grace. At $149 MSRP, this is an 8.5/10 value proposition. At $199.99 on Amazon, it's closer to 8/10. Either way, the price is fair for what you're getting.

Ethan Mercer, Editor-in-Chief

Specifications

size52 inches
typeCeiling Fan
power120V
featuresLED light kit
warrantyLifetime

Overall Rating

8.2
out of 10
Clara
8.5
Ethan
7.5
Critics (1)
8.5

Related Reviews

Review History

Initial review from real source data

Initial review from real source data

Editorial Independence

Our reviews are based on research from trusted expert sources. We may earn commissions from affiliate links, but this never influences our ratings or recommendations. How we score · Editorial policy · Report an error

Related Fans

Rowenta VU5670 Turbo Silence Fan
9.0/10
$100.00
Vornado 630 Medium Air Circulator
8.6/10
$99.00
Dyson Pure Cool TP01
8.5/10
$399.00
$149

Lowest Price Vendor Auto-Selected